Public Health

Comprehensive Summary

Diamond-Smith et al. evaluate the effectiveness of using social media as a recruitment method for a COVID-19 and social networks study pertaining to Indigenous and Native American communities in California. Diamond-Smith et al. recruited participants through Facebook, Instagram ads, community partner outreach, and a Qualtrics research panel. They collected data using a 30 minute online survey with 50 questions, and identified fraudulent responses using re-CAPTCHA, IP geolocation, and other verification methods. In total, 5099 survey responses were received, however, 3926 were excluded from the data due to fraudulence or poor quality. As a result, the final data consisted of 137 Native Americans and 72 Mesoamerican Indigenous participants. Overall, it was seen that recruiting Native American and Mesoamerican Indigenous communities through social media was ineffective. Even when using screening tools such as CAPTCHA and honeypot questions, a large proportion of the responses were either fraudulent or generated by AI bots. These bots were successful at bypassing most security methods, which resulted in many data entries being rechecked or discarded completely. Ultimately, Facebook was an ineffective recruitment method, whereas the research panel yielded the most authentic data at a lower cost, although the number of eligible participants remained limited. The authors conclude that not only is it challenging to recruit hard-to-reach populations through the use of social media, but AI bots are becoming sophisticated enough to interfere with recruitment efforts, making it harder to collect authentic data from real people. New outreach strategies and stronger verification tools are needed in order to maintain data quality in online public health research.

Outcomes and Implications

Social media has often been an effective tool in recruiting various populations, including minorities, for public health research. However, there has been limited research on how effective social media is for recruiting Indigenous and Native American communities and the challenges researchers face during outreach. Understanding the barriers to online recruitment helps ensure that public health studies reflect the needs and perspectives of Indigenous communities. Through their research, Diamond-Smith et al. found that there is a growing threat of fraudulent AI-generated responses that has direct implications for the reliability and authenticity of online data collection. Furthermore, it was noted that since the survey used for recruitment was only provided in Spanish and English, language barriers could have been a significant limitation, and culturally and linguistically tailored recruitment methods are important for reaching a larger population. Overall, the study’s findings highlight a greater need for advanced fraud-detection systems in filtering out responses generated from AI-bots and the implementation of culturally informed recruitment strategies as online research outreach methods become more widespread.

Our mission is to

Connect medicine with AI innovation.

No spam. Only the latest AI breakthroughs, simplified and relevant to your field.

Our mission is to

Connect medicine with AI innovation.

No spam. Only the latest AI breakthroughs, simplified and relevant to your field.

Our mission is to

Connect medicine with AI innovation.

No spam. Only the latest AI breakthroughs, simplified and relevant to your field.

AIIM Research

Articles

© 2025 AIIM. Created by AIIM IT Team

AIIM Research

Articles

© 2025 AIIM. Created by AIIM IT Team

AIIM Research

Articles

© 2025 AIIM. Created by AIIM IT Team